Are you nervous about your upcoming disability hearing? When I talk to my clients before their hearings, one of the most common things they talk about is how anxious they are. Many of them seem to be on the verge of an anxiety attack when they enter the hearing room. I attempt to prepare my clients for this big day by letting them know what the atmosphere of the hearing will be like, the types of questions they will be asked, and what they should talk about (or not talk about) when they answer those questions. I have seen some attorneys and representatives who do not prepare their clients for their hearings at all, or they do so in the waiting room right before the hearing. It is my practice to speak with each of my clients a day or two before the hearing; we have plenty of time to prepare, but it’s close enough to the hearing that the client will remember everything we talked about. I usually spend between 45 minutes and an hour letting them know exactly what to expect at the hearing. Of course, no matter how well-prepared we are, hearings can take many unexpected turns and there can always be surprises. However, I know from experience how the majority of hearings are conducted and what issues are likely to arise, and I am able to explain to my clients what they should expect.
Fist, it is important to remember the hearing is supposed to be informal. In other words, most of the Administrative Law Judges do not follow strict trial rules and procedures. Does this mean you can talk out of turn and interrupt others at the hearing? No; you still must wait your turn and be respectful. Most judges give everyone an opportunity to talk, so I believe it is important to be patient until you are given the chance to speak. In my experience, judges aren’t really interested in your financial distress or in the fact that your neighbor down the street receives Social Security disability benefits even though he has nothing wrong with him. The judge is focused on a single issue: how your disabling condition prevents you from working.
I have appeared at hearings in front of Administrative Law Judges from all over Indiana and the United States. When I prepare my clients for their hearings, I explain the three categories of questions asked by most of those judges:
Does this list cover everything you can expect at your hearing? Probably not, because all hearings are unique depending on the circumstances. However, I have appeared at hundreds of hearings, and in my experience most hearings follow this outline. When I prepare my clients for a hearing, I’m not just helping them get ready; I’m making sure I am ready and have all the information I need to present a good case. I do not want surprises at the hearing; I want to know what my client is going to say and why they are saying it. In my opinion there can be good and bad ways to answer questions at your hearing, and a well thought-out explanation to the judge may help him better understand your disability claim.